Member-only story
It is hypocrisy at its height.
The documentary reminds me of another documentary, Sour Grapes. The people who pride themselves on their exquisite taste in art and wine can’t even tell the difference between the authentic and the forged.
This seemingly most spectacular art forgery began in 1995, when Ann Freedman, the director of the Knoedler Gallery, a 165-year-old gallery that went into business 25 years before the Metropolitan Museum of Art was founded, bought an untitled piece by Mark Rothko from Glafira Rosales, a woman who lived (and still lives) in Long Island that no one in the art world had heard of. Freedman bought the piece for an astonishingly low $750,000. In 2004, it was sold to art collectors Domenico and Eleanore De Sole for $8.3 million. The painting itself, a black and orange composition, is beautiful. (Even Rothko’s son said so.) David Anfam, an expert on Rothko, after having seen a photo of the painting, said that it was genuine. (He denied in court that he had seen the painting in person.)
The painting came with no provenance except for a story about a mysterious Swiss collector who had a wife and kids but at the same time was also gay and had ties to a gay gallerist. However, it was not difficult for Freedman to get documents from different experts to, in one way or another, endorse the painting. No one investigated further into this mysterious Swiss collector. The gallery was only too thrilled to have “discovered” all these untitled paintings by Rothko, Pollock and the like.
It turns out that during the period 1995 to 2011, Freedman had bought and sold more than 60 Abstract Expressionist canvases from Rosales, sometimes with profit up to 800 percent. Rosales, not long after she was arrested by the FBI in 2013, entered a guilty plea and confessed that the paintings are all fakes. The artist behind these mind-blowing masterpieces is indeed a Chinese man who lived in Queens, Pei-Shen Qian. Qian has since fled to China. The whole thing was orchestrated by a con man in the art world, José Carlos Bergantiños Diaz, who was the boyfriend of Rosales and also the father of her daughter.
The whole story is revealed in this latest documentary on Netflix, so I will not go into further details here. However, I do have a question. When these art…